Two very powerful organic insecticides made from different oils are available to homeowners. Here are some notes about their applicability to your particular insect problem.
Horticultural oils are typically made from petroleum distillates, although some are vegetable extracts. They are suffocation agents, producing a bubble that doesn’t allow the insect to breathe, and are most effective on soft bodied insects that don’t have sharp shells that can break the bubble.
Yet they can be effective for insects like Mexican Bean Beetles that have multiple generations feeding at the same time: horticultural oil will kill the eggs and larvae, breaking the insect’s lifecycle and preventing a lot of future damage, even if it doesn’t kill all the adult beetles.
Horticultural oils have an advantage over insecticidal soap (another organic insecticide). They can partially dissolve the “honeydew” left by some insects that results in blackened leaves, making it easier for rain or a stream of water to clean off the foliage. My Pieris shrubs tend to get a lot of honeydew, so I spray them every other month during the growing season with horticultural oil to keep the leaves green.
Horticultural oils are also used as “dormant oils” on fruit trees and ornamentals in late winter or early spring to control overwintering insects. The application rate may be higher for dormant spray applications than for plants that have leafed out (too high a rate can damage growing foliage). I spray my roses with horticultural oil prior to bud break in late winter, to kill any overwintering mites that might infect the plants with the Rose Rosette virus.
Neem oil is made from seeds of the Neem tree, a mahogany relative native to India. Neem oil can kill soft-bodied insects by suffocation like horticultural oil, but its primary use is as a stomach poison for feeding insects. It also has some fungicidal activity, primarily for powdery mildew. Neem oil is somewhat more expensive than horticultural oil.
Horticultural and Neem oils are both certified for organic gardening, and are readily available locally in concentrates and ready-to-use sprays.
Be sure to read the label and follow the instructions when using any pesticide – organic or not – around the home.
Jim Janke is an Extension Master Gardener Volunteer in Haywood County.
For more information visit haywood.ces.ncsu.edu, or call the Haywood County Extension Center at 456-3575. ©2020 NC State University.